TECHNICAL PAPER #46
UNDERSTANDING WOOD WASTES
AS FUEL
By
Jon Vogler
Published by
VITA
1600 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 500
Arlington, Virginia 22209 USA
Tel: 703/276-1800 * Fax:
703-243-1865
Internet: pr-infor@vita.org
Understanding Wood Wastes as Fuel
ISBN: 0-86619-260-3
[C]
1986, Volunteers in Technical Assistance
PREFACE
This paper is one of a series published by volunteers in
Technical Assistance to provide an
introduction to specific state-of-the-art technologies of
interest to people in developing
countries. The
papers are intended to be used as guidelines to help people choose technologies
that are suitable to their situations.
They are not intended to provide
construction or
implementation details.
People are urged to contact VITA or a similar organization for further
information and technical assistance if they find that a
particular technology seems to
meet their needs.
The papers in the series were written, reviewed, and
illustrated almost entirely by VITA
Volunteer technical experts on a purely voluntary
basis. Some 500 Volunteers were
involved
in the production of the first 100 titles issued, contributing
approximately 5,000
hours of their time.
VITA staff included Marjorie Bowens-Wheatley as editor, Suzanne
Brooks handling typesetting and layout, and Margaret Crouch
as project manager.
VITA Volunteer Jon Vogler, the author of this paper, is
widely published in the field of
recycling. His book
Work From Waste, published by the Intermediate Technology development
Group, Ltd., London, England, describes how to recycle
paper, plastics, textiles,
and metals. Mr.
Vogler, an engineer, worked in Oxfam's "Wastesaver" program in
developing
countries. He has
done much research in the field of recycling waste materials.
VITA is a private, nonprofit organization that supports
people working on technical problems
in developing countries.
VITA offers information and assistance aimed at helping individuals
and groups to select and implement technologies appropriate
to their situations.
VITA maintains an international inquiry Service, a
specialized documentation center, and a
computerized roster of volunteer technical consultants;
manages long-term field projects;
and publishes a variety of technical manuals and papers.
UNDERSTANDING WOOD WASTES AS FUEL
by VITA Volunteer Jon Vogler
I. BACKGROUND
We can define wood wastes as wastes arising from human
operations
on wood; extracting it from forest, woodland, and
plantation;
converting it into planks and other "stock";
fabricating these
into products--buildings, furniture, tools, and thousands of
other items; and finally, discarding these when broken or
even
just "out of fashion."
To this definition may be added "nature's
wastes," such as leaves, twigs, and branches that fall
from the
tree due to natural causes such as aging, wind, lightning,
or
animal disturbance.
With that broad definition in mind, tree and wood wastes can
be
categorized as follows:
Forest Wastes
Conversion Wastes User
Wastes
Thinnings(*)
Bark
Sawdust
Reject Trees
Sawdust
Shavings
Leaves
Slabs(*)
Sander Dust
Bark
Edgings(*) End
Trim(*)
Branches(*)
Rejects(*) Off
Cuts(*)
Topwood
Veneer
Clippings
Stumps and Roots(*)
The use of waste wood is as old as humankind.
During early civilization,
stone-age people likely used wood waste to fuel fire
since greenwood is very difficult to burn.
Manufacture of items
from wood also began very early.
Wood was used for tools and
weapons and, no doubt, cut-offs from the production of long
implements were used for short axe-handles or pegs, while
chips
and shavings served as kindling.
This paper describes a number of uses of wood wastes as
fuel,
which is how the greatest proportion of wood wastes are
used.
Non-fuel uses of wood wastes, for example in building
materials,
industry, and agriculture, are described in another paper,
"Understanding
the Non-fuel Uses of Wood Wastes."
The issue is
acute, because the poor throughout the world, both urban and
rural, continue to consume fuelwood and charcoal faster than
it
can be renewed.
Meanwhile, an insatiable demand for paper made
from wood pulp, wooden building components, furniture, and
other
goods also contributes to deforestation.
Economical use of wood
wastes instead of new wood helps to preserve forests and
woodland
in developed countries and is becoming essential to survival
of
the poor in many parts of the Third World, as fuel becomes
more
scarce.
(*) widely used directly as domestic fuel, as kindling, and
as the
raw material for charcoal.
This paper concentrates on three main uses for wood wastes
as
fuel:
o Burning solid wood
wastes or sawdust;
o Using sawdust and
tiny wood pieces to make small compact fuel
pellets
(briquettes) that can be burned in a manner similar
to solid wood;
o Making charcoal, a
widespread (mainly cottage) industry for
converting wood
wastes into a lightweight, smokeless fuel.
Some experts describe certain wood waste processes as having
singular applications.
Many procedures for processing wood
wastes, however, can also accommodate a wide variety of
agricultural
waste products such as husks and hulls.
II. BURNING SOLID
WOOD WASTES
COMBUSTION IN WOOD-BURNING STOVES
All wood contains moisture; even kiln dried wood has an
eight
percent moisture content.
When the kindling is first lit, white
smoke, containing a large percentage of water, rises from
the
wood. As the fire
begins to burn, long tongues of yellow flame
indicate that the volatile substances, natural oils, and
resins
within the wood have been released.
This chemical breakdown of
the wood into "char" and volatile gases occurs at
150-200 [degrees] C. The
gases do not all actually ignite until a temperature of 540
[degrees] C.
has been reached. In
an open fire, these volatile gases are given
off into the air in the rising smoke and hot air and do not
reach
their flash point.
Thus much of the fuel value is lost.
Following
this, the wood burns with small white flames and hard, clear
outlines as the remaining fibrous matter (lignin) and carbon
ignites.
MODERN "AIR-TIGHT" STOVES
Many years ago, stoves were made of cast iron panels bolted
together. More
recently, welded steel sheet has replaced cast
iron. Cast iron
holds heat better, but is prone to cracking under
mechanical or thermal shock.
Although fire cement is sandwiched
in the joints, a cast iron stove is never as air tight as a
sheet
steel stove. Sheet
steel cannot crack, but may warp if overheated
unless made of thick (13 guage) plate.
Sheet steel stoves are
easier to move, being much lighter, and require little
maintenance.
The welded seams remain airtight for the life of a stove.
Fire Control in Air-Tight Stoves
Control of the rate of burning is achieved by controlling
the
amount of air escaping, and the speed and amount of air that
passes through the mass of fuel.
Various features of stove design
affect this:
o The fuel rests on
a grate that allows air to pass through it
from below.
Simple grates are usually parallel steel
bars,
close enough to
prevent fuel from falling through the spaces
between them.
o An important
requirement is an air-tight firebox constructed
so that all air
admitted is controllable, by one of the
following:
-
Air intakes positioned below the grate
control the
quantity of air
entering and fuels passing through the
firebox.
This may vary from no air to a strong draft
that
causes the fire
to blaze.
-
Opening and closing the stoking doors varies
the air
supply to the
fire, but the doors are usually above the
grate level, so
air passes over, not through the fuel and
the draft is
not effective.
-
Dampers regulate the draft by varying the
size of the
chimney
opening. The damper is a hinged flap in
the flue,
the pipe from
the firebox to the chimney.
-
Baffle plates:
the volatile gases are given off at 150-200 [degrees] C.
If these hot
gases escape up the chimney their
fuel value is
lost. Baffle plates of steel or cast
iron
obstruct the
gas flow, and ensure the gases are heated to
their flash
point and radiate additional heat before
escaping.
During "secondary combustion" the
gases given
off from the
heated fuel-wood are drawn away from the
main fire.
A secondary inlet admits air and the gases
spontaneously
ignite if they are at a sufficiently high
temperature.
o Heat exchangers,
sometimes called smoke chambers or radiators,
extract the
maximum amount of heat from the hot fire
gases.
They are additional chambers that can be
bypassed
during
kindling. By moving a valve, the hot
gates may be
directed through
them when the fire has reached a certain
temperature.
Heat exchangers and other parts of the fire
boxes of stoves
are often wrinkled or patterned in order to
provide an
increased surface area for transferring heat.
This
is one of the
functions of the patterns and traditional
scenes that are
cast into the surfaces of many Scandinavian
stoves.
o Heat output can be
increased by forced draft provided by an
electric fan
running in a steel tube. This increases
both the
supply of air for
burning and the rate at which heat is
removed
(transferred to the surrounding area).
Advanced Stove Designs
Five basic designs have evolved for wood-burning stoves,
though
there are as many variations as there are stove
manufacturers.
The main differences concern how air moves through the
stove.
1. Updraft Stoves
allow air to enter through inlets at the
bottom, move up
through the grate into the burning wood, and
flow out of the
flue. Many updraft stoves have
secondary air
inlets above the
wood for secondary combustion of the gases
when the stove is
burning well.
2. Air enters the
bottom of Diagonal stoves then moves diagonally
through the fuel
to the fire in the back of the stove. A
secondary air
inlet above the wood assists secondary combustion.
Heat exchangers
are often fitted.
3. Air enters near
the bottom of Crossdraft stoves and leaves
near the bottom
at the back of the stove. Secondary
combustion
of gases occurs
in the main fuel bed.
4. Downdraft stoves
force air and combustion gases down through
the burning
fuel. Air enters at or near the top of
the stove
and travels down
through the grate to leave through a flue at
the bottom.
These stoves are smokey when not burning
properly,
unless fitted
with a flap valve to allow the smoke to
leave at the top
of the stove until the fire is burning
fully.
5. Front end
combustion or "S" draft stoves.
In this model, logs
burn from front
to back much like a cigar. The primary
draft
enters through
the front and passes over the fuelwood, which
then burns
towards the back. Baffle plates force
the hot
volatile gases to
double back over the fire in order to reach
the chimney
flue. They encounter secondary air and
burn with
high efficiency
if the stove temperature is high.
Water Heating
Many wood-burning stoves are jacketed.
That is, the firebox is
surrounded by a jacket of water, which, when heated,
convects
(moves upwards because hot water is less dense or lighter
than
cold water) or is pumped away to be used.
Back boilers are also
common. Water to be
heated flows through a chamber (usually made
of copper) behind the flue.
Water heating reduces the heat radiated
from the stove itself; however, the heated water may be
passed through radiators to heat areas away from the stove.
WOODBURNING IN THE THIRD WORLD
Fuelwood accounts for at least half of all the wood used in
the
world each year and for more than 85 percent of wood used in
Third World countries.
No other source of energy is available (or
seems to be) on a scale large enough to satisfy the billion
people who depend upon fuelwood.
Demand is now outstripping supply
and the situation worsens with constant population growth,
as
fuel must be collected or purchased at a constantly
increasing
expenditure of labor or money--a burden that falls mainly on
women.
Part of the solution is, of course, to grow more trees.
Part is
to make better use of the fuelwood resources that
remain. The
introduction of cooking stoves that use less fuel than open
fires
or traditional stoves can reduce the labor of fuel gathering
and
conserve fuel, so as to extend the time available for
long-term
measures (tree planting) to take effect.
However, the "advanced"
stoves described above are too costly for most Third World
users.
Research programs have therefore been launched over the past
few
years to develop better stoves than those in common use, yet
still simple, robust, of low cost, and suitable for local
manufacture
and unskilled use.
Some Typical Improved Stove Designs
Early efforts concentrated on the development of massive
stoves
made from mud. Later
more durable designs known as "pottery
insert" stoves were made from pottery by skilled
artisans. These
can be coated with an outside layer of mud to increase
stability,
durability, and insulation.
These high mass stoves were, however,
found to suffer from a number of design flaws.
The stoves themselves
absorbed tremendous amounts of heat, which while useful
for space heating in some areas, used up excessive amounts
of
fuel. The mud or
clay walls disintegrate in rain or high humidity,
and the individual construction of the stoves precludes
effective quality control unless the builder is very well
trained. As a result,
many high mass stoves use more fuel, not
less, than traditional stoves.
Because of these and other problems,
subsequent research focused on smaller, portable metal and
ceramic stoves based on traditional designs.
The result of scientific
research by VITA and others has been a series of guidelines
for the design of such stoves.
Critical points include close
matching of pot to stove to ensure maximum contact with the
fire,
insulation to minimize heat loss, a grate to ensure good
combustion,
and control of the air supply to regulate burning.
These
portable stoves also lend themselves to quality control and
mass
production, as exact templates can be put into the hands of
artisans who are trained in their use.
Portable metal cooking stoves are proving to be much in
demand,
especially in some urban areas of developing countries.
This type
of stove efficiently burns scraps that could not be
effectively
used on an open fire.
Its fuel economy is excellent.
Because it
contains the heat well, the cook can remain seated close to
the
stove while cooking.
This is not possible with the open fire or
traditional coal-pot stove.
With improved stoves, smoke is reduced.
They are also more stable than the traditional coal-pot,
and the pot can be stirred vigorously without the risk of
upsets.
The charcoal-burning metal stove, known in Kenya as the
"Jiko,"
is over 90 percent inefficient.
To replace it, the Umeme Stove
has been developed by UNICEF's Appropriate Technology
Section in
Nairobi. It is
designed so that the cooking pot sits inside the
stove. There is a
sloping inner chamber made of metal, which is
insulated from an outer metal cladding by a layer of
ash. A newer
model, known as the Kenyan Ceramic Jiko, uses a fired clay
liner
in the metal cladding.
VITA's work in Somalia and in West Africa has also yielded
improved
stoves based on traditional designs.
In Somalia, soapstone
stoves carved to rigorous specifications to increase
efficiency
are finding a ready market.
And in Burkina Faso, Mali, Guinea,
and elsewhere, traditional metal designs have been upgraded
and
artisans trained in their production.
The use of templates in
these areas has permitted the manufacture of large numbers
of
high quality stoves, thus bringing down the unit cost and
making
them more attractive to purchasers.
Commercial stoves, including an American product known as
the Zip
Stove, are also currently being promoted in developing
countries.
The Zip Stove, manufactured from light weight galvanized
steel, comprises a cylindrical combustion chamber with a
removable
grate and an outer casing, with a layer of refractory (heat
resistant material) insulation between them.
This stove, and
others like it, is much more costly than the improved
traditional
stoves that are produced locally, and may not be any more
efficient.
Dangers of Simple Stoves
Fuel efficiency is not the only concern in the design of
simple
stoves. Burning any
carbon fuel produces poisonous carbon monoxide.
In an enclosed room this can be very dangerous.
Simple
stoves are not very safe in this respect.
For example, the average
carbon monoxide content of gases emitted by traditional
charcoal
stoves ranges from 0.9 percent to 0.3 percent.
By contrast,
European safety standards recommend carbon monoxide
emissions
should be not more than 0.0005 percent in any enclosed
area. Even
so called improved stoves are no better in terms of gas
emissions.
The average carbon monoxide flue gas composition of the
Zip Stove for burning wood is 1.3 percent and for charcoal 2
percent. When damp
wood is burned, the production of carbon
monoxide increases 1.8 percent with considerable quantities
of
smoke.
At present, there are no reliable measurements of carbon
monoxide
and other emissions from open fires, but indications are
that the
women who cook with these fires and improved stoves suffer
respiratory
damage that is equivalent to smoking several packs of
cigarettes a day.
The solution to this problem lies in creating designs with a
chimney to remove gases from the room, the lethal carbon
monoxide
in particular, and an air-tight firebox with baffles to
achieve
more efficient burning of the combustion gases.
BURNING SAWDUST
Huge quantities of sawdust are produced in sawmills and
carpentry
workshops all over the world, but it is rarely recycled
effectively.
It cannot be used for paper making because the fibers
are too short. It
will not burn on an open fire, except in the
smallest quantities.
Its lignin structure makes it unsuitable for
fertilizer, animal feed, or biogas production.
Unless it contains
very high proportions of resin, it is difficult to use in
briquettes
without expensive binders or very high pressures.
Only
large sawmills may find it economical to buy a briquetting
press
and possibly to carbonize (make into charcoal) the finished
briquettes, let alone to recover the tar and combustible
gases
that are the by-products of the carbonization process.
Nonetheless,
there are several ingenious ways people have found to burn
sawdust.
Tin Can Stove
The single chimney tin can stove is the simplest homemade
stove
to use sawdust for cooking.
A hole is cut in the bottom of one
side of a five-gallon can.
A short length of broomstick is placed
horizontaly in the hole so that it reaches just to the
center of
the can. Another
stick is held upright in the center of the
stove, with the ends of the two sticks touching.
The can is
filled with sawdust, tamped down with a wooden block during
filling and sprinkled with water to keep the dust level
down. The
sticks are removed, some diesel oil or kerosene is dripped
through the hole where the center stick was.
The oiled area is
lighted with a burning rag through the air hole at the
bottom.
The mass will burn for six to seven hours.
The burning rate can
be controlled by obstructing the air flow through the bottom
passage. A simple
"trivet" (three-legged stand for cooking pots)
can be placed on top of the can and a cooking pot or kettle
can
be heated on it.
Food cooked on this stove will tend to smell and
taste of wood-smoke.
Other Sawdust Stoves
The double drum stove is even larger and more complicated,
but
still inexpensive to construct.
It consists of a 30-gallon steel
drum, supported on a false floor inside a 55-gallon steel
drum. A
drawer, opening below the false floor, provides draft and
catches
dropping ashes, which are then easily removed.
A hole in the
center of the false floor and the inner barrel bottom lets
air
pass up to the fuel, and ashes fall into the drawer.
A tightly
fitting lid covers the outer barrel and two stovepipes
exhaust
smoke. It should
stand at least two feet from any combustible
material and be set on a fireproof floor pad.
CAUTION:
DO NOT
open the lid while the fuel is burning.
A serious flare-up may
result.
With dry sawdust and a good draft, one charge of this stove
can
heat a room 7 meteres square for six to eight hours with no
tending.
Wetter fuel heats less but lasts longer.
During the first
two hours of burning, there is enough heat at the center of
the
lid to boil water or cook.
As burning progresses, the heat on the
lid is distributed more toward the rim.
Stoves can also provide
hot water. A coil of
metal (preferably copper) pipe placed inside
the stovepipe will heat water that is circulated through it.
Mexican Water Heater
A sawdust-fire water heater is widely used in Mexico.
The sawdust
is lightly sprinkled with petroleum or fuel oil and loosely
packed in polythene bags that are sealed.
The full bag is known
as `combustible' and is sold by grocers and hardware stores.
Two
combustibles can heat enough water for a bath.
The special water
boilers have a grate at the bottom, on which the
combustibles are
burned. Above the
grate is a chimney surrounded by a water jacket
with a water inlet and outlet that are plumbed into the
household
hot water system.
III. COMPACTING WOOD
WASTES
SAWDUST BRIQUETTES
The alternative to having a special stove for burning
sawdust and
small wood wastes is to compress these into a briquette--a
small,
compact fuel pellet.
The average calorific value of briquetted
wood waste or sawdust is 4,000 kilograms per cubic
centimeter, so
every 100,000 tons of briquetted wood waste will be
equivalent to
42,850 tons of fuel oil, making it a valuable fuel that will
repay substantial costs of manufacture and transport.
High-Tech Briquetting Processes
The process is based on the recognition that most wood waste
is
self-bonding at fairly high temperatures and requires no
added
binder. Sawdust is
preheated to above 163 [degrees] C to destroy its
"elasticity" and to eliminate moisture.
This decreases the weight
by about one-third and almost doubles the heating value per
pound. It is then
moistened and briquetted hot without a binder.
Pressure is retained during cooling.
The resulting briquettes
are firm and strong enough to withstand rough handling and
resist weathering to an extent that permits shipment and
storage,
if protected from rain.
To achieve briquettes of the necessary strength and
hardness, the
moisture content of the wood waste should be around 10
percent,
although in some cases, machines are capable of handling dry
wood
chips. Dryers may
take the form of rotating drums through which
hot air is blown or steam-heated plates and pipes over which
the
waste is cascaded. A
large proportion of the material may be
needed to provide sufficient heat to dry the feedstock from
a
high moisture level.
It is usually necessary to grind the waste
to a suitable size and, before doing so, to strain it to
remove
stones, soil, or metal, which would damage the grinder.
Briquetting machinery must be robust and powerful.
Attempts to
produce simple, low-cost, low-power machines for small-scale
operations have not been successful to date. Pressures of up
to
1,000 kilograms per square centimeter can be involved.
To keep
die temperatures low and avoid burning the briquettes, dies
need
water cooling.
Machines need motors giving between 25 and 100
kilowatts for every ton per hour of throughput, although not
all
this is absorbed during operation.
Many manufacturers of wood pulp and other wood products use
sawdust and other wastes as fuel for their manufacturing
processes.
The wood wastes are briquetted in an ongoing process.
One
such process uses a machine that screws the waste wood
(sawdust,
shavings, and other scrap, ground to the size of oatmeal
particles)
first into a compression chamber at a pressure of 3,000
pounds per square inch (211 kilograms per square
centimeter). At
the outlet from this chamber, a secondary head cuts the
compressed
material into a spiral ribbon and forces it into a mold
under a pressure of 25,000 (1757.7 kilograms per square
centimeter)
to 30,000 pounds per square inch (2109.24 kilograms per
square centimeter).
Friction at this extreme pressure generates
enough heat to achieve self-bonding.
The molds are parallel to
the axis of the wheel.
The mold is closed by a hydraulic piston
that retracts as the mold fills.
When one mold has been filled,
the wheel rotates to align the next with the compression
chamber.
The molds are water cooled, and, by the time the wheel has
moved
full circle, the briquette is cool enough to eject.
The machine
produces 4 by 12 inch briquettes that are fed manually into
the
factory's furnaces.
For mechanical stoking an extruder is used that forces the
waste
through one-inch round holes as continuous rods, which are
cut
into one-inch lengths by rotating knives.
The machine is small
enough to be mounted on a truck and powered by a truck
motor.
It is far less expensive to transport briquettes than loose
waste, so briquetting machinery should operate where the
wood
waste arises.
Briquetting presses are best located at sawmills,
furniture factories, or oil mills.
However, if these are far from
populations or industrial centers where there are markets
for
fuel briquettes, transportation costs may not make the
operation
cost-effective. The
finished briquette may need protection from
reabsorption of moisture and should be stored in dry areas
or
packed in sacks.
Packing in plastic film or cellophane may be
necessary. Careful
handling and transportation are needed to
prevent crumbling.
Other processes include:
o Briquetting
between rollers with cavities that produce egg-shaped
briquettes in
sizes between one and four centimeters.
o Pelleting where
waste is forced by pressure rolls through the
holes in a
die-plate (product size 0.5 centimeter);
o Cubing--a
modified form of pelleting (product size 2-5
centimeters);
o
Rolling/Compressing--where fibrous material is wrapped around
a rotating shaft
to produce a high density roll or log
(product size
10-18 centimeters diameter).
Simple Sawdust Briquettes
Various attempts have been made to devise methods by which
people
in rural areas can use sawdust to make briquettes.
The simplest
idea, for areas where dung is shaped by hand and sun dried
for
use as fuel, is that the dung cakes will burn longer if wood
ash
is added. Most
efforts have been devoted to making simple machines.
Most hand-operated machines use a mechanical lever to apply
greater compacting pressure than is possible with hand
molding.
The length of the lever arm determines the briquetting
pressure
and it is important that the mold be sturdy enough to
withstand
this. Approximately
four to five hours work of by a competent
blacksmith or welder are all that is needed for the simplest
devices. A steel
pipe provides a good briquetting mold.
Earth rams, simple hand-powered presses currently in use for
making building blocks, can be easily modified to make
briquettes.
The Combustaram, similar to the CINVA-Ram and Tersaram,
is commercially available or can be locally manufactured.(*)
Another device consists of a piston that reciprocates in a
cylinder
on which there is a hopper to feed the sawdust (or other
agricultural waste) to be compacted.
The piston is driven by a
hand-turned crankshaft, on which a flywheel is mounted.
There is
a simple device to eject the briquette, which is about 30
millimeters
in diameter and 10 millimeters thick.
Approximately 50
kilograms of briquettes can be produced in about eight
hours.
A larger machine is powered by a single bullock.
It consists of
two sets of pistons and cylinders and turns at about four
rpm to
produce two briquettes per revolution.
The capacity is around 150
to 200 kilograms of briquetted fuel per eight hours.
(*) Both machines were designed, fabricated, and tested by
the
School of Applied Research in India.
Further details can be
obtained from the National Research Development Corporation
of
India, 20-22 Zamroodpur Community Center, Kailash Colony
Extension,
New Delhi 110 048, India.
A Thai businessman, Sayan Panpinij, in collaboration with
VITA,
has developed an extrusion machine that transforms rice
husks
into burnable logs.
Approximately 75 kilograms of rice husk fuel
logs are produced per hour from each of twin extrusion
heads,
with a density almost double that of firewood.
The machine is
powered by a 20-horsepower electric motor and works best
with
husks that have been ground and dried to reduce
moisture. The
machine can be operated by one person who feeds the rice
husks
into the hopper on top of the machine, removes the fuel logs
from
below the extruder, and stacks these for cooling.
It is estimated
that three people will be necessary to operate four
machines. The
VITA extruder can also produce fuel logs from sawdust.
These have
a higher heat value than rice husk logs, produce less smoke
and
ash when burned, and reduce wear and tear on the
machine. The
device is relatively new and has not yet been manufactured
outside
of Thailand.
The life and maintenance of this extrusion machine is a
primary
consideration for the user.
When the device is used for extruding
rice, the screw will need to be replaced every 120
hours. The
extrusion cylinder has a life of about 450 hours and will
probably
need to be rebored every 150 hours for its most efficient
operation. When the
device is used for extruding sawdust, however,
the life of the machine is nearly double.
Depending on
temperature, quality of the heater unit, and the length of
operation,
the life of the heat unit varies between 240 and 350 hours.
In a four-unit plant, it is estimated that capital and
operating
costs can be replaced within one year.
RETTING AND PRESSING
Partially decayed and processed cellulosic materials give a
much
higher heating value than if the materials are simply
dried. For
example, dried rice straw (10 percent moisture content) has
a
heat value of only 3,000 BTU/pounds (7 million
joules/kilogram
[J/kg] or 0.0698 gigajoules/kilogram [GJ/kg]), but this will
increase to between 7,500 (17.4 million J/kg or 0.0174
GJ/kg) and
12,000 (28 million J/kg or 0.0279 GJ/kg) when the material
has
partially rotted before it is dried.
In the Philippines, the
MAPECON research group has set up a pilot plant producing
such
fuel, with 25 percent moisture content and an average of
10,000
BTU/pounds (23 million J/kg or 0.0232 GJ/kg) which they call
`green charcoal,' at the rate of one ton per hour.
The group
reports that it is very competitive with other types of
fuel.
Retting--soaking in water for several days or longer at
normal
air temperatures--allows chopped, moistened woody residues
to be
biodegraded (partially decayed).
This process is used to produce
mats that can be pressed into fiberboard, but a simple hand
press
can also be used to make briquettes from retted agricultural
residue or wood wastes.
The lever is made from steel pipe and the
timber mold has holes on each side to allow water to escape
during pressing.
BUNDLING
Tying brushwood into compact bundles for ease of
transportation
and use is the simplest means of densifying wood
wastes. Twigs,
straw, hay, dry leaves, and other woody wastes are bundled
all
over the world, using cord, vines, wire, or any locally
available
tying material. Where
large-scale bundling is carried out, stands
or racks have been developed to assist in the bundling
process,
and to allow for drying before use.
Brush bundling machinery is
also available, but indescriminate use can seriously damage
ground cover, leading to soil erosion and loss of fertility.
IV. MAKING CHARCOAL
FROM WOOD WASTES
In contrast to the heavy weight and high smoke level of the
wood
from which it is made, charcoal is a light, smokeless fuel
of
high calorific value.
THE CARBONIZATION PROCESS
When wood is heated in the absence of air, changes take
place in
several stages. At
100 to 120 [degrees] C, water is emitted into the air.
Green wood contains between 50 to 70 percent water, which
must be
evaporated before the wood temperature can rise higher.
Carbonization
(conversion into carbon or charcoal) begins at 270 to 400
[degrees]
C. The reaction,
technically named pyrolysis, gives out heat.
The
wood chars and gives off gases and vapors--carbon dioxide,
carbon
monoxide, hydrogen, methane, water vapor, methanol, acetone,
tar,
and pitch.
The yield of charcoal and its composition depend on the
species
of wood, the carbonizing temperature, and other
factors. Yield is
generally about 25-40 percent by weight of dry wood.
Although low
carbonization temperatures produce a higher yield (because
the
charcoal still contains matter that has not been given off
as
gas) the charcoal quality is poor.
It smokes and flames.
Temperatures
that are too high, on the other hand, shorten the life of
equipment, so care should be taken to keep carbonizing
temperatures
between 400 and 700 [degrees] C.
The energy value of the gases represents some 40 percent of
all
the heat value of the original dry wood.
Some of the gases contain
valuable chemical compounds.
Unfortunately, production on an
industrial scale is necessary before it is economical to
recover
these compounds. In
small-scale processing, however, they help
maintain burning in the kiln.
TYPES OF KILNS
Charcoal is made by placing wood in a kiln, igniting it in
the
air, and then, when it is burning thoroughly, reducing the
supply
of air almost completely.
Many types of kilns are in use.
Some
are industrial size, some are much smaller.
They will be described
here in order of complexity, starting with the simplest.
The Earth Kiln
An earth kiln usually occupies about eight square meters of
ground. Logs of wood
are placed on the ground with space between
them to allow air passage in the early stages.
The pile is built
to a meter high and covered with leafy vegetation 30 cm
deep.
Stakes are set in the ground around the pile to support a
wall
made with interleaved branches or scrap corrugated
iron. The kiln
is then lit and allowed to burn fiercely until smoke comes
out at
various places. The
pile is then covered with earth and left to
burn for about two days.
Burning is complete when the kiln slumps
down to half its original height.
More soil is added to exclude
air totally for three or four days until the kiln is
cold. It is
uncovered, allowed to cool for a few hours, then the
charcoal is
put into sacks for sale.
It is reported that two experienced
charcoal makers can produce about six tons of charcoal a
month by
this process, which needs no capital money just a sack, a
spade,
and an ax.
The CUSAB or Oil Barrel Kiln
Kilns for carbonizing small wood pieces are made from oil
drums,
45 gallons or 250 liters in volume.
Each oil drum is fitted with
holes of approximately five centimeters.
Threaded pipe fitting
the same approximate diameter are then welded to the
holes. The
screw connectors can then be fitted with plugs to cut off
the
emerging air. Holes
should face the wind and a stick can be used
to keep the openings clear of debris during the early hours
of
burning. It is
reported that five to six kilns can produce four
to five tons of charcoal per month.
Although kilns have a short
life, the pipe fittings can be reused, and the low cost of
oil
drums makes this a cost-effective technology.
The Steel Kiln
The steel kiln can produce an average of 500 kilograms of
charcoal
every two days from two and a half tons of wood, depending
on moisture content and density of the timber used as
feedstock.
This represents up to 12 tons of charcoal per month.
The kiln is
simple to operate and does not normally require attention at
night nor water for cooling purposes.
It is, however, an expensive
object and very hard work to transport across rough roads.
Two strong men can barely handle two kilns, including
loading,
unloading, and moving to new sites.
It has been designed to
withstand rough usage and extreme temperature
conditions. There
are no underground fittings.
To operate, logs are placed, with kindling between them, in
the
lower cylinder, which rests on eight smoke boxes.
The lower
cylinder is then densely packed with logs. When full, its
rim is
filled with mud to form an air seal and the upper cylinder
is
mounted on top. The
upper cylinder is also packed to a height
such that the top cover does not quite meet the cylinder.
Flaps
of the smoke boxes are open for lighting.
Then, when plenty of
smoke is emitted, some flaps are closed.
In approximately an
hour, the cover will settle down onto its rim.
Chimneys are then
fitted to the smoke boxes.
If blue smoke comes from a chimney,
the chimney is removed and the smoke box below it is capped
for
fifteen minutes to reduce burning.
After 16 to 24 hours, smoke
will cease. Each
chimney can then be removed and the smoke box
closed. Cooling
takes 8 to 12 hours.
Other Simple Kilns
There are many other simple kiln designs available.
One version
uses a drum lying on its side.
It has been found very satisfactory
by the Fiji Department of Forestry.
In the Philippines tests
have been made on various improved simple designs, mostly
consisting
of two drums welded together to increase capacity to 160
kilograms of wood.
Improved air vents and chimneys can cut heating
time to four hours, and yield up to 40 percent
charcoal. In
Papua New Guinea, two cylinders made from 44-gallon drums,
lying
on their sides over a stone or concrete fire trench, produce
high
quality charcoal. A
group of drum kilns wired together will allow
the heat to be distributed more efficiently and produce
charcoal
faster.
Retorts
Retorts are designed to use the gases (including condensed
gases
or liquors) more effectively.
They give a higher yield because
they carbonize all of the raw materials.
Kilns on the other hand,
burn away some of the raw material in order to provide the
necessary
heat. Heat for
carbonization is provided by otherwise useless
materials such as coconut shells, pigeon pea bushes, palm
leaves, and woodworking scraps.
A tar condenser may be fitted, in
which the gases are condensed and the tars collected for use
in
road construction, preserving timber, or sealing flat
roofs. Some
retorts can recover gases that are directed to the firebox
where
they are burned to fuel the process during its later stages,
saving solid fuels.
Industrial Processes
Increased sizes and complexities of kiln are available as follows:
Mobile Vertical Bath Kiln:
This 19-foot-high kiln weighs nearly
three tons and has a built-in crane to assist in erecting it
on
site, lifting and lowering the cover during operation.
No concrete
foundation is required.
It takes only 48 hours to produce
four tons of charcoal, which can be discharged directly from
a
chute into bags.
Liquors (condensed gases) are recovered.
Demountable Vertical Kiln:
This semi-permanent design can be set
up in an area of forest.
When cleared, it can be re-erected on a
new concrete foundation in another area.
It can be moved using
large road vehicles.
Skilled erection is, however, a requirement.
This kiln can produce around 3,000 tons of charcoal per
year.
Permanent Vertical Kiln:
This is available in sizes to produce
between 5,000 and 10,000 tons of charcoal per year.
The material
is handled mechanically and can be passed through a
continuous
dryer. Little labor
is necessary.
Larger Kilns: These
are usually horizontal and include continuous
drying, briquetting, and bagging plants.
Fluidized Bed Kilns:
Fluidization is a well known technique, a
developing technology in such applications as coal
conversion,
packaged coal-fired boilers, and gas turbine power
generation.
Within the timber industry, wood-fired fluidized bed
furnaces
have become commercially available for steam raising.
There is
increasing interest in processing wood waste into upgraded
fuels
such as gas, charcoal, or oil fluidized beds.
Further details may be obtained from manufacturers.
BRIQUETTING OF CHARCOAL
If charcoal can be sold near the site where it is made,
transportation
and storage costs will not be high.
If it is to be
transported a long distance or sold later when the market
price
is better, it is desirable to compress it into small, dense
briquettes. This
also uses the fine dust, which cannot otherwise
be sold or used. The
disadvantage is the cost of a binding substance,
such as starch from cassava.
If no binder is used, a
briquetting press with high working pressure is needed and
such
machines are expensive (about US$100,000), but easily
obtainable
and not difficult to operate or maintain.
So far, no company has
produced an inexpensive small briquetting press that
produces
sufficient pressure to make briquettes that do not crumble
without
a binder, so large presses have to be used.
Some models need
to be fed by at least eight steel kilns, which result in
additional
transportation costs.
Charcoal Briquetting Processes
The production of charcoal briquettes may be accomplished
either
by preparing the charcoal first and then pressing it, or by
preparing wood briquettes to be carbonized after
forming. One
method produces semicharcoal briquettes by preheating
sawdust
until the lighter gases have been given off and tar begins
to
distill. The partly
charred sawdust, brownish in color, is then
cooled to 100 [degrees] C, moistened with water, and pressed
into a mold.
Another method heats dry sawdust in molds, under low
pressure,
until it has partially carbonized, then applies a pressure
of 350
pounds per square inch until carbonization is complete.
The
resulting briquettes are further heated to drive off gases
that
would create smoke.
Another process distills finely ground wood to produce
granulated
charcoal, which is mixed with the wood tar produced in the
process
and briquetted. The
briquettes are reheated in a retort to
drive off and recover the lighter fractions of the tar.
The
remaining particles may then be bound firmly together to
form a
dense briquette. This
process is sometimes referred to as"coking."
It is reported that these processes are commercially
unsuccessful
because the charcoal briquettes produced are too brittle
to be used. An
alternative is for finely ground charcoal or
charcoal dust to be mixed with a suitable binder before
being
pressed into uniformly-sized, strong, dense briquettes, free
from
charcoal dust.
Practical briquetting operations entail four steps:
1. Preparation of
charcoal fines. Lump charcoal is
crushed, then
milled using a
screen with 1/10 inch or 1/8 inch holes to
produce material
with enough fines to fill the voids between
the larger pieces
and to prevent them from being crushed
during
briquetting.
2. Mixing to coat
the charcoal particles with a film of binder.
A kneader-type,
double shaft mixer is often used.
Another
method, however,
involves simultaneously feeding pre-crushed
charcoal and
cassava flour into a hammermill. The
mixture is
stirred
continuously, then steamed until the flour forms a
binding paste.
3. Briquetting the
mixture between two cylindrical rolls that
rotate in
opposite directions. Each roll is
designed with
rows of hollowed
half molds, aligned so the halves match.
Hundreds of
briquettes can be produced at every turn of the
rolls.
4. Drying the
briquettes continuously or in batches.
Dryers are
similar to
agricultural dryers in operation.
Briquettes
produced with
asphalt or pitch binders do not need artificial
drying, only
cooling.
Binders
To produce satisfactory briquettes economically, the binding
substance must meet certain requirements.
It must produce a
briquette strong enough to withstand damage during
transport,
storage, and stoking.
Exposure to weather must not cause crumbling
or softening and, during use, the heat must not cause
disintegration
and loss of fine pieces through the grates.
It must
burn without smoke and unpleasant smell and not be too
dusty.
Ideally the binder should have as high a heat value as the
charcoal.
Binders fall into three categories:
inorganic materials, organic
materials, and fibers.
o Inorganic
materials, such as cement and silicate of soda
are appropriate
for wood fuel. These substances are
poor
because they
give more ash, reduce the heat value, and fall
apart while
burning.
o Organic
materials such as tar, pitch, resin, and glue
usually increase
the heat value and create no extra ash.
o Various types of
fibrous material may serve as binding
agents.
The cheapest is hydrated wood fiber-wood
waste--ground,
pulped wood
waste, which, when dry, binds together
in the same way
as paper.
Some binders permeate the material to be briquetted; others
coat
the surface. Starch
binders, such as cassava, corn, and others
are smokeless, but not moisture resistant.
They are normally used
in the proportions of four percent (dry basis).
Tar, pitch,
asphalt, and sugar cane molasses are used in less than 30
percent
of the cases. They
are moisture resistant but not smokeless.
This
is no drawback in industrial uses, such as smelting and
heating,
but would be inappropriate for home fuel or cooking.
Secondary distillation (heating a second time) can drive off
the
smokey gases, but increases cost and does not completely
remove
objectionable smells during burning.
A good smokeless charcoal is
one that contains at least 75 percent fixed carbon and not
more
than 24 percent "volatile" (able to be emitted as
gases) matter.
Uses of Briquetted Charcoal
Briquetted charcoal has many industrial uses and can be used
as
domestic fuel as well.
The product is a high quality industrial
fuel for production of steel, cement, copper, rubber, gun
powder,
and other products.
In the chemical industry, very pure briquettes are used as
activated carbon for air and water purification, for
filtration,
decolorization, purification of sugar, and as a chemical
catalyst. Activated
carbon commands prices five to six times
higher than those of briquetted charcoal.
REFERENCES AND RESOURCES
Appropriate Technology International has several reports on
the
use of both charcoal and wood stoves.
For information contact
ATI, 1331 H Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20005, USA.
Intermediate Technology Publications (ITP) includes over a
dozen
titles on this subject in their catalogue.
The catalogue can be
ordered from I.T. Publications, Ltd., 9 King Street, Covent
Garden, London, WC2E 8HW, United Kingdom.
Institute of Natural Resources (1978).
Proceedings of the Seminar
on Wood as an Alternative Energy Resource.
Suva, Fiji, University
of the South Pacific.
Volunteers in Technical Assistance (VITA) also offers a
number of
titles.
BRIQUETTING
"Briquettes From Wood Waste," Madison, Wisconsin,
Forest Products
Laboratory, U.S.
Department of Agriculture, 1947.
Bryant, B.S. et al, Fuel Briquettes from Fibrous Residues
Using a
Hand-Operated Lever
Press, Volunteers in Technical Assistance,
Arlington,
Virginia, USA.
Cosgrove-Davies, Mack.
"Understanding Briquetting," a Technical
Paper by Volunteers
in Technical Assistance, Arlington,
Virginia, USA.
Currier, R. A., Manufacturing Densified Wood and Bark Fuels,
Oregon State
University Extension Service Special Report 490,
1977.
Klages, A., 1953, Economic Aspects of Wood Briquetting,
Australian
Timber Journal 19,
pages 414-441.
Smith, A. E., Flynn G., & Breag G. R., A Profile of the
Briquetting of
Agricultural and
Forestry Residues, Tropical Development and
Research Institute,
127, Clerkenwell Road, London, EC1R 5DB,
United Kingdom.
SAWDUST
"Briquettes From Wood Waste," Madison, Wisconsin,
Forest Products
Laboratory, U.S.
Department of Agriculture, 1947.
Bryant, B. S. et al, Fuel Briquettes from Fibrous Residues
Using
a Hand-Operated Lever
Press, Volunteers in Technical Assistance,
Arlington,
Virginia, USA.
Currier, R. A., 1977, "Manufacturing Densified Wood and
Bark
Fuels."
Oregon State University Extension Service
Special
Report, 490.
Foley, G., Moss, P., and Timberlake, L., Stoves and Trees,
Earthscan,
1984.
Joseph, S., and Hassrick P., Burning Issues:
Implementing pilot
stoves
Programmes--A guide for Eastern Africa.
London: Intermediate
Technology
Publications, 1984.
Klages, A., 1953, Economic Aspects of Wood Briquetting,
Australian
Timber Journal 19,
pages 414-441.
Reineke, L. A., 1955, Briquettes from Wood Waste, Forest
Products
Laboratory Report
No. 1666-13.
Smith, A. E., Flynn G., & Breag. G. R., A Profile of the
Briquetting
of Agricultural and
Forestry Residues, Tropical Development
and Research
Institute, 127 Clerkenwell Road, London,
EC1R 5DB, United
Kingdom.
Wartluft, J., Double Drum Sawdust Stove, a technical
bulletin
published by VITA,
Arlington, Virginia, USA. ISBN
0-86619-109-7.
CHARCOAL
Charcoal Making for Small-Scale Enterprises:
An illustrated manual.
Geneva:
International Labour Office, 1975.
Grato, N., "Charcoal Manufacture," Liklik Buk
pp: 132-133, Lae,
Papua New
Guinea: Liklik Buk Information Centre,
Lae, Papua
New Guinea, 1977.
Little, E. C. S., 1978, The Mini CUSAB Kiln for Rapid
Small-Scale
Manufacture of
Charcoal from Scrub, Coconut Wood, and Coconut
Shells, Appropriate
Technology 5 (1): 12-14.
Medrano, E. M., "Design, Fabrication and Operation of Drum
Kilns
for Charcoaling
Coconut Shells." Technology
Journal 1 (2): 26-35,
1976.
Papua New Guinea Building Research Station,
"Manufacture of Charcoal
by Retorts,"
Boroko, PNG Building Research Station Technical
Bulletin No. 10.
Richolson, J. M., and Alston, A., Coconut Palm Wood Charcol:
A Potential Source
of Heat Energy Suva, Fiji Department of
Forestry (mimeo),
1977.
Testing the Efficiency of Wood-Burning Cookstoves,
Volunteers in
Technical
Assistance, Arlington, Virginia USA, 1985.
The Comparative Performances of Kenyan Charcoal Stoves, ITDG
Stoves Project,
Technical Paper No. 1.
Vil lanueva, E. P., and Banaag, N. F., "Sawmill Waste
Charcoal for
Domestic Use and
Its Quality as Compared to Ipil-Ipil (Leucaena
glauca benth) and
Coconut (Cocos nucifer L) Shell Charcoals,
Project No. 33-11,
Second Progress Report, The Lumber, August-September
1963.
SOURCES OF HELP AND INFORMATION
Asian and Pacific Coconut Community (APCC)
Box 343
Jakarta, Indonesia
Department of Agriculture
Box 14
Nuku'alofa, Tonga
Fibre Building Board Development Organization, Ltd.
1 Hanworth Road
Feltham, Middlesex TW13 5AF
United Kingdom
Forestry Division
Ministry of Agriculture
Fisheries and Forests
P.O. Box 358
Suva, Fiji
Forest Products Research and Industries Development
Commission
(FORPRIDECOM)
NSDB college
Laguna 3720
Philippines
ITDG
Wood Stoves Project
9 King Street
Covent Garden, London WC2E 8HW
United Kingdom
New Zealand Forest Service (NZFS)
Private Bag
Wellington, New Zealand
The Principal
Kristian Institute of Technology of Weasisi (KITOW)
P.O. Box 16
Isangel, Tanna
New Hebrides
South Pacific Bureau for Economic Cooperation (SPEC)
Box 856
Suva, Fiji
Timber Research and Development Association
Hughenden Valley
High Wycombe
Bucks, United Kingdom
Tropical Products Institute (TPI)
56 Grays Inn Road
London WC1X 8LU
United Kingdom
United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO)
P.O. Box 707
A-1011
Vienna, Austria
Volunteers in Technical Assistance (VITA)
1815 North Lynn Street, Suite 200
Arlington, Virginia 22209 USA
Wood Stove Group
Eindhoven University
Post Bus. 513
5600MB, Eindhoven, Netherlands
CARBONIZING EQUIPMENT
Aldred Process Plant
Oakwood Chemical Works
Sandy Lane
Worksop, Notts S80 3EY
United Kingdom
SUPPLIERS OF BRIQUETTING EQUIPMENT
Air Plant (Sales). Ltd., (Spanex)
295 Aylestone Road
Leicester, LE1 7PB
United Kingdom
Aldred Process Plant
Oakwood Chemical Works
Sandy Lane
Worksop, Notts S80 3EY
United Kingdom
CeCoCo
Chuo Boeki Goshi Kaisha
P.O. Box 8
Ibaraki City
Osaka 567
Japan
Eco Briquette APS
P.O. Box 720
Frederikshavn DK-9900
Denmark
Fred Hausmann AGH
Hammerstrasse 46
4055 Basel
Switzerland
IMATRA-AHJO Oy
Sukkulakatu 3
SF-55120
IMATRA
Finland
Universal Wood Limited
11120 Roselle Street
Suite J
San Diego, California 99121
USA
VS Machine Factory
90/20 Ladprao Soi 1 Road
Bangkok, Thailand
Woodex International, Ltd.
P.O. Box 400
Terminal A
Toronto, Ontario
Canada M5W 1E1
========================================