A. TOKO & A.H. BOKONON-GANTA
National Plant Protection Agency (SPV), Porto-Novo, Benin
Background
Significant losses are registered in maize harvest because of pests. The most destructive of these pests is the Larger Grain Borer, Prostephanus truncatus (Horn) (Coleoptera: Bostrichidae), which was accidentally introduced from America. The SPV has recommended different methods including binary pesticides with organo-phosphate and pyrethroid bases for use on the maize grains. The main problem with this method of control is the fact that farmers have to shell the maize. Furthermore the risks linked to farmers' use of non-recommended products to treat the maize husks led the SPV to experiment on preservation with less toxic insecticides but this did not yield any positive result. Consequently, following the impressive results being recorded in the area of biological control of the pests, the SVP recommended and extended the integrated control approach based mainly on biological control. This paper is an up-date of the achievements made in the control of P. truncatus, and the prospects of an integrated and sustainable management of the pest in Benin.
Introduction
Considerable loss is recorded during the storage of food crop harvest due to the activities of pests. Most post-harvest pests are transported from the farm during harvest to the storage space. It is therefore necessary to protect harvest against the loss occasioned by these pests through the implementation of strategies incorporating different control measures in order to ensure sustainable protection of harvested crops.
Achievements
The Insect Pest Complex
The major stock pests in Benin belong to the Coleoptera and Lepidoptera orders. These pests infest staple food crops and make them unsuitable for consumption. Among insects in the Coleoptera order that are harmful to maize are the weevil, Sitophilus zeamais, the grain borer, Rhizopertha dominica, the Tribolium spp., the toothed butterfly, Oryzaephilus surinamensis, the red cucujid, Cryptolestes ferrugineus. The major Lepidoptera (moths) are the meal moths, Corcyra cephalonica, the corn-moth, Sitotroga cerealella, Cadra cautela, and Plodia interpunctella which may cause considerable damage to maize grains and maize flour in storage. The larger grain borer, P. truncatus, accidentally introduced from America and Mexico has, in the last ten years, added to the number of these pests. P. truncatus is different from all the other pests because it is more prevalent in maize, other stocked products and even construction materials. Maize stock infestation by P. truncatus translates into large losses for small producers.
Major Control Measures
Sanitation measures
In the face of the permanent danger posed by the destruction of agricultural products in storage, different measures including preventive and chemical methods have been recommended by the SPV to protect harvest from the activities of the above pests. Thus, in order to protect stored staples, the SPV recommends amongst others, sanitation methods (the sorting of cobs and/or grains, cleaning the storage spaces after each season), timely harvesting and chemical treatments.
Chemical control
To ensure good preservation of stock, the use of insecticides, especially the Actellic PP (2% Pirimiphos Methyl) was recommended for most of the pests, and where P. truncatus infestation is suspected, the Super Actellic PP (Pirimiphos methyl & Permethrin) and the Sofagrain PP (Deltamethrin 0.5% & 1.5% Pirimiphos methyl) at the rate of 50g/100kg of grain was recommended for the treatment of maize grains.
The results achieved in the protection of stock vary considerably among farmers who are in the habit of using pesticides. In Benin, the damage caused by the Larger Grain Borer on the stock of small farmers who store in husks in traditional granaries is much more severe than that of large-scale producers who have better storage spaces, and who adopt SPV recommendations. The surveys carried out to evaluate the effectiveness of this method revealed that farmers usually do not have the time to de-husk the maize before storage and continue to store their stocks in husks. The application of dust powders offers only a limited surface protection to the stocked products. The product does not reach the insects inside the husked cobs before the application of the insecticide, thereby limiting the effectiveness of this control measure. The results obtained in the use of the above pesticides in the treatment of maize in husks is therefore unfortunately rather unimpressive. Concerned with protecting their stock at all cost, and at least cost, farmers persist in the use of different un-recommended products, especially those meant for the treatment of cotton crops and others obtained from doubtful sources.
In view of the situation described above, and the farmers' desire for a product for the treatment of maize in husks, the SPV focused on the use of chemical products available in the immediate environment of the farmers which constitute less risks than cotton pesticides. For this purpose, a test protection method against stocked husked maize was designed and installed in the Ouémé province, South East of the country.
The pesticides used were "Kinikini" CE (Cyfluthrin 9.6 g/l & Malathion 400 g/l) and Sherlone CE (Cypermethrin 30 g/l & Phosalone 500 g/l) at a rate of 50 ml of the commercial product in 2 litres of water per ton of maize. The result was that none of the pesticides was effective in protecting the maize in husks. As from the fourth month, the percentage of damage and loss recorded was so high that the farmers were obliged to get rid of their stock.
Biological control methods
Biological control is the main component of the integrated control method and can guarantee durable protection of stock against the Larger Grain Borer. Based on the quite impressive results obtained in this area, the SPV has decided to extend the achievements of this biological control through different activities.
Monitoring the prevalence of the pest
To do this, the SPV initiated and/or carried out a number of actions in collaboration with the GTZ Supra Regional project on the control of the Larger Grain Borer. Among these actions are prompt field observations, planning workshops, collaborative seminars on the development of post-harvest technology, and releases of P. truncatus natural enemy, the predator Teretriosoma nigrescens Lewis. Continued exploration aimed at identifying other infestation sites, and the release of T. nigrescens with a view to increasing the population to ensure more effective action in stores.
Training and mass production of beneficial insects
Aware of the important role of the biological control in the implementation of the integrated control approach in the sustainable management of grain store pests, and with due consideration to the performance of one of its natural enemies, T. nigrescens, and its release whose result was encouraging in some countries in the sub-region such as Togo and Ghana, SPV considered it important to set up and run a unit to rear the natural predator of P. truncatus. This is what justified the training on the techniques of rearing T. nigrescens, the natural predator of the Larger Grain Borer. The purpose of this training is to boost the technical skills of the SPV in the implementation and methodology for rearing the natural enemy.
This five-day training took place at IITA-Benin with the financial support of the GTZ Supra Regional Project. It facilitated the training of an SPV technician on the different stages of rearing, especially the installation and maintenance of the pure culture of the pest, and mass breeding of the beneficial insect.
Prospects
Since the introduction of the pest, and after several years of control measures, it has become obvious that the control of the Larger Grain Borer is better done collectively than individually. The collective control is accomplished with the co-operation of the different Departments, institutions and organisations involved in stock protection, and farmers who are the major beneficiaries of the methods to be applied. This explains why, in addition to the control measures themselves, the SPV has embarked on other activities including the sensitisation of populations on the real problem posed by the pest, in order to launch an effective and sustainable control of the pest.
Generally, the objectives of the different activities are:
* |
to provide more information and further sensitise producers, traders, consumers and political/administrative authorities of the existence of, and risks posed by the pest, and |
* |
to establish and ensure that an integrated and sustainable pest management system is put into operation in all affected areas. |
In order to achieve these objectives, the following major actions have been planned for:
* |
Continuous monitoring of the pest in all agro-ecological zones of the country; |
* |
Boosting the capacity of the T. nigrescens mass production unit installed at the SPV; |
* |
Releases of T. nigrescens in 30 localities that are known to be infested, and monitoring of the effect of the introduction of the natural enemy; |
* | Installation of 10 demonstration stores in five local governments (two stores per locality) with high prevalence of the P. truncatus to enable farmers monitor the impact of the introduction of T. nigrescens in a real life situation, so as to promote integrated stock protection; |
* |
Review and editing of technical forms in French and several national languages in order to further sensitise and educate producers on the usefulness of good preservation of food crops; |
* |
Organisation of special days for exchanging ideas on the biological control of the P. truncatus. Two days, one in the South and one in the North, involving all field site workers for exchanging ideas have been scheduled. |
* |
These days will concentrate on sensitising them and exchanging notes on their experiences on the activities of P. truncatus and the technological control measures available; |
* |
Creation and broadcast of rural radio programs on national stations: local rural radios, and private radios all over the country. |
Conclusion
The concern of the SPV is to further entrench the actions carried out on the control of P. truncatus, and to implement them within an integrated pest management system with a view to ensuring an effective and sustainable control of the pest.